- Title: Comanche
- Author: Brett Riley
- Publisher & Release: Imbrifex Books, Sept 1st 2020
- Length: 336 pages
- Rating & Recommend: 🌟🌟🌟⚡ probably
Here is the synopsis from Amazon:
Like a cylinder in a six-shooter, what goes around, comes around.
In 1887 near the tiny Texas town of Comanche, a posse finally ends the murderous career of The Piney Woods Kid in a hail of bullets. Still in the grip of blood-lust, the vigilantes hack the Kid’s corpse to bits in the dead house behind the train depot. The people of Comanche rejoice. Justice has been done. A long bloody chapter in the town’s history is over.
The year is now 2016. Comanche police are stymied by a double murder at the train depot. Witnesses swear the killer was dressed like an old-time gunslinger. Rumors fly that it’s the ghost of The Piney Woods Kid, back to wreak revenge on the descendants of the vigilantes who killed him.
Help arrives in the form of a team of investigators from New Orleans. Shunned by the local community and haunted by their own pasts, they’re nonetheless determined to unravel the mystery. They follow the evidence and soon find themselves in the crosshairs of the killer.
Thank you to Imbrifex Books for the advanced copy in exchange for an honest review! All opinions are my own.
Raymond and LeBlanc are two Private Investigators from New Orleans, and they are called to Comanche, TX, to help investigate some brutal murders that have the local authorities stumped.
The settings were extremely well done, whether 1800’s Comanche or present day was being described. The local flavor was there plus the small town politics and family drama. I loved how much Ray and Leblanc love food too, all the talk about NOLA specialties had me hungry. The weather and layout and setting in general played a big role in the book, and it was well done so that I felt like I was there.
The murderer…well… It’s either a person, a ghost, or a person emulating a ghost, and he is a pretty scary entity. I stay away from most ghost and horror stories out of fear but this one was manageable. The legends surrounding Comanche and The Piney Woods Kid and then ghosts in general were pretty well done, and I think they took a predictable but interesting route to track down and stop the killer.
I liked the characters too, I would definitely read more from Ray and Leblanc and McDonald, the psychic.
A few notes: the action was definitely good and heart pounding at times but got a little bit repetitive. The book also does not use quotes, which provided for a smooth reading experience but was an adjustment to get used to. As far as how repetitive the book was in general, I felt like maybe it was a novella or shorter work that got brought to novel length.
Lastly, time for the OneReadingNurse medical rant©: I get that Raymond is an alcoholic and this was done tastefully. It felt real, the struggle is definitely real. What I didn’t love was how after Ray’s hand got pulverized – yes, pulverized – they were making a huge deal out of him taking a prescribed percocet. I get that people can get addicted to anything but 5/325 (mg oxycodone to tylenol) is a standard percocet and for the love of everything I get concerned when patients are afraid to take narcotics for legitimate acute problems. I don’t love seeing that feeling perpetuated in shows because pain and lack of activity post procedure is a much bigger issue than the taking of a medication as prescribed.
Anyway – yes I would recommend it but be aware of the format in case the style will throw you off
P.S: I really am trying to stay active on booksta and here but my brain and body and life in general suck right now. I’m trying but will only be writing for author ARC requests and book tours for a bit. All my plans for self published fantasy month… Ah… Like I said, I’m trying
7 replies on “ARC Review: Comanche by Brett Riley”
I’ve heard mixed things about this one. I always love your medical advice to authors though 😂
Do you have a vacation planned? The work that you do sounds grueling. Add 2020 to the mix & you definitely deserve a break.
Ugh, NOLA food 😭😭😭😭😭😭 I think that writing style would throw me too much 😶 hope you get back into a groove and your year improves 🤗
LikeLiked by 1 person
I could go for a vacation and a Po’boy, I can’t see the year getting any worse but who knows
LikeLiked by 2 people
Grits 🤤 a legit vacation would be pretty damn amazing
I hope things get better! Great review.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I mean they can’t get much worse so that’s something! And thanks!
LikeLiked by 1 person