***Tree wolf image by chic2view (Wyrd & Wonder 2022)! Please do not alter the image & credit the artist ❤***
I am so glad to be reading The Summer Tree with the Wyrd & Wonder readalong! My favorite discussion format is a few chapters a week with questions, so this is perfect
I’ll be uploading my weekly discussion question responses to this thread!
Week One – Questions hosted by Imyril! Do check out her blog for tons of great fantasy content!
1) How are you reading along with us? Is this a first time or a reread? Show us your book cover!
I am reading via a paperback and this is my first time reading. I have read Mists of Arbonne by GGK. Honestly if I had just read the synopsis of The Summer Tree I think I would have never picked it up since the blurb is borderline corny!
2) The prose style is as distinctive as calling the prologue an overture. How are you finding it?
I don’t dislike the prose but he has the weirdest way of naming characters. Paul! Schafer! Paul Schafer! In 3 paragraphs GGK can call Paul 4 different names and it drives me nuts since there’s only one Paul. He does it with Dave Martyniuk too – there’s only one Dave and the scattered use of last names is just grating on me.for some reason
Some of his similes are a bit weird too – did anyone else catch the part at the end of chapter six where the lake was immediately sexualized and then that whole scene was allegoric to the loss of innocence? GGK makes some “interesting” stylistic choices
All in all, it is quick reading and easy to first prose
3) Each visitor gets a moment to define them before they arrive in Fionavar. What are your first impressions of our travellers? Any you particularly like / dislike?
I just don’t think it was enough! In that sequence GGK barely touches on the women while introducing parts of what motivates the men. I’ve already got Paul picked out as the sacrificial lamb but I have no thoughts on the others yet, except that they seem inconsistent.
Kim is a cutout that clearly has some type of Seer abilities, and while Jennifer kept saying she was frightened she was able to face down the Prince with claws at the ready.
That said – I’m down for fantasy that focuses more on story than characters
4) …and what do you make of the characters & politics of Paras Derval?
This is only to the end of chapter 6 – I am curious as to what end game they are playing! We finally learned of the conflict and curse in Fionavar, but the politics and alliances are still fairly undefined.
I might be the only one but the characters seem like cardboard cutouts right now. Loren – mage. Gorlaes – bad guy. Metran – doddering old mage. Ysanne – mysterious sorceress. Jaelle – angry priestess. Diarmuid – rakish Prince playing his own political game.
The king is the only one I thing has layers so far!
5) The obvious question: would you accept Loren’s invitation? Given the reception from Diarmuid and Gorlaes, would you regret it?
Back in college I would have gone in a second, no questions asked like get me out of here! Now I have too much adult stuff going on, animals to care for and such. I would have been ok with the reception of the prince sneaking me alcohol 😂
6) How/Do you judge Loren for keeping so many secrets from the visitors?
I don’t judge him – yet – it’s too hard to know what the visitors role will be at this point. Obviously there is a lot going on and while some of it is starting to become clear, we don’t really know what Loren’s endgame is yet. I think if he had told them any more they would have balked too
7) There is a lot of worldbuilding so far! Intriguing or overwhelming? Anything standing out for you? And as always: any other thoughts this week?
I think it’s a bit overwhelming, but at this point I have read enough epic fantasy to just absorb what I can and let the rest wash over me as part of the reading experience.
The part sticking out to me is the Legend of The Summer Tree and the hanging kings for sure, I love when magic and rulers/kings are tied to the land